Tag Archives: State Correctional Institute Pittsburgh

Inmate Correspondence Continues with Drawing of Western Pen Whistle

If you’ve been following the blog posts related to the Western Pen Whistle Tone, you may be interested to see this drawing from inside the institution.

This past winter, the State Correctional Institute (SCI) Pittsburgh declined my request for a visit to see, photograph, and learn more about the whistle. Since I’m interested in telling the stories about the sounds that become ringtones within this project, I’m also interested in showing the sources from which the sounds come. Over in the Manchester/North Side neighborhood of Pittsburgh, the whistle is easy to hear–every day at 8:40pm, when it goes off. It’s just not easy to see. Since I wasn’t able to take or use any actual image of the whistle, I used this scan of a vintage postcard of Western Penitentiary as the icon for the tone.

The drawing at the top of this post was sent by the male inmate who wrote to me in August after seeing my appearance on WQED’s Filmmakers Corner. In his initial letter, he asked about my choice to publish the sound of the whistle as a ringtone and expressed his reaction (as someone who hears the sound on a daily basis).

You can read our initial letter exchange here. The gentleman who drew this picture also suggested some ringtone-ideas. Since I told him I take requests for tones, I will record and publish one of his suggestions.

I appreciate that this man took the time to write back to me and to share his drawing of the whistle.

Leave a comment

Filed under Locally Toned (all posts), Project Updates, Ringtone Research

Ringtone Feedback: Letter Exchange with an Inmate from SCI Pittsburgh

Recently I received and replied to a letter from an inmate at SCI (State Correctional Institute) Pittsburgh. He shared his reaction to one of the tones in the project. I assume that he’d seen my appearance* on WQED‘s television show, Filmmakers Corner (hosted by Minette Seate), because the letter was addressed to me in c/o the show.

My appearance on the episode began with a shortened version of my *Mobile* Ringtone Performance. One of the tones that I played and discussed was the Western Penitentiary Whistle Tone. The man who sent the letter, who’s presently incarcerated at SCI Pittsburgh, wanted to know why I had recorded the whistle.

Locally Toned as a public work of art, is produced through a method of social practice. Instead of making and publishing a series of ringtones that I think would well-represent this region, I ask Pittsburghers for input (what tones should be recorded) and to collaborate (by working with me on audio recordings in the field). Participants answer these questions with me: “What does Pittsburgh sound like?” and “Which of these sounds should turned into ringtones to be shared with the public, free of charge?”

So lots of people have had a say regarding what sounds they’d like to hear as ringtones, but few residents of this area have provided formal (written) feedback regarding a published tone. How do people who live here feel about the content that is curated and published within the project? This man experiences the sound of the whistle in his daily life. Because he took the time to send a letter, he’s opened up dialogue about the tones as functioning signals and sounds. The letter-exchange allowed me to reflect more deeply about how experiencing a sound is very much shaped by the physical space within which it is heard. Since I consider his letter direct feedback from a stakeholder (a resident of this region), in the spirit of community accountability (Locally Toned is a public work of art), I’ve decided to publish our letters.

*The episode, BTW, will air again on WQED 13.1 on Saturday, October 23, 2010 at 10:00pm.


Filed under Locally Toned (all posts), Project Updates

Western Penitentiary Whistle Tone (Anonymous Collaborator)

Scan of an engraving of the Western Penitentiary, Allegheny City, near Pittsburgh, PA, from Wikimedia Commons

“I have an idea for a ringtone for all of my cronies who did time in Western Pen.  …there’s a whistle that blows every evening around 8:40. That sound means, to all who are ‘in the know,’ to ‘take it in,’ in prison yard vernacular.”

Today’s contributor, a male, in his fifties, is a former convicted felon and prefers to remain anonymous. I’ll call him A. He spent more than 5 years incarcerated in at Western Penitentiary, the institution in that location now is the State Correctional Institute Pittsburgh (SCI Pittsburgh). Not long ago, I met with him to record the ringtone, and to discuss the sound of the whistle from his perspective.

To ‘take it in,’ A. explained, “Means to wrap up whatever you are doing because it’s time to report back to your prison cell. You can also hear that sound in neighborhoods nearby,” said A., “but on the inside, at night, when it goes off, it means it’s lock up–you have to stop what ever you are doing, what ever conversation you are having and report back to the place where you sleep. While living with the sound in there, it was a reminder of the absence of freedom and control. Outside those walls, for me, it serves as a reminder that evokes strong feelings of gratitude now, but also a hints of trepidation. I am still under the auspices of that bureaucracy [on parole] and I had some terrifying experiences there.

My personality and mentality were very different during those years–I was involved in nefarious and criminal activity (with drugs) and I spent years in the Restrictive Housing Unit, which is ‘the hole,’ or solitary confinement. That’s where they put you when you can’t behave in jail. The whistle sounds different when you’re in solitary confinement–you can hear the activity of people going back to their cells. In solitary confinement, you feel acute loneliness and despair.”

Including this tone in the project was very important to me. A question I think about frequently when working on this project is: How does sound shape space? In working on this tone with A.,  I reconsidered space to include mental space–one’s psychological state.

“People may realize this or not, but for a prisoner, when that whistle goes off, your mentality changes, and so must your actions. You stop what you are doing and think, ‘What am I going to do when I get back to my cell?'”

Here sounds serve as a signal for permission or restriction. They can determine or affect one’s actions and abilities or limitations on them.

The same sound resonates differently for those outside the institution. For instance, a friend of mine who grew up in Sewickley, said that as a child, every once in a while, her family could hear the sound of the whistle when the wind carried the sound just the right way along the river. When they heard it, her father would say, “Sounds like somebody escaped!”


The night A. and I ventured out to a neighborhood overlooking the institution to record the audio, I told him I thought I wouldn’t be able to capture decent audio on the first try. The whistle is not the sort of mechanical sound (like Russ Kovacic’s Welding Tone) that you can ask someone to re-do if your guess-timate for setting audio levels is incorrect. But we had good luck–the tone, on the first try, turned out wonderfully!

There weren’t any people around on the street the night we recorded the audio,  or I would’ve asked folks in the neighborhood what they thought of the whistle.


I contacted SCI Pittsburgh to find out more and to allow the institution an opportunity to share what they felt was important about the sound with Locally Toned readers.

The institution declined my requests to enter the site and answer my specific questions and let me photograph the whistle, but spoke briefly with the institution’s Public Information Officer, Carol Scire, on the phone. She told me that the whistle is located in the building’s Power Plant (built in 1939), and she issued this statement to Locally Toned:

“In the event of an emergency, SCI Pittsburgh would sound the whistle, and then activate the Rapid Notify System– which is an automated telephone system that dials listed telephone numbers within a two-mile radius of the prison to inform individuals of an emergency – and immediately notify Pennsylvania State Police and local law enforcement.  The whistle sounds every day at approximately 8:30 p.m. to signal the recall of the inmates to their housing units.  The whistle may also be used for drills or exercises.

We want to assure the public that we are committed to public safety and are taking all necessary precautions to alert them in the event of an emergency.”


There is no reference to the whistle at the Pennsylvania Department of the Main Branch of the Carnegie Library of Pittsburgh in Western Pen file.

An antique Western Penitentiary postcard I purchased from eBay in April 2010

In other research I learned that the institution has a long history in relation to prison reform spurred on by Quakers. There’s an excellent article on The Pennsylvania Prison Society‘s website called “Prison Reform in Pennsylvania” by Norman Johnston, Ph.D. This extended quote referencing reform history at Western Penitentiary is from the Pennsylvania Correctional Industries site:

“…prison reformists focused on determining the causes of criminality. The roots of crime were thought to be found in inadequate training in school and church. Pennsylvania’s response to this penal philosophy was the construction of two state penitentiaries designed to rehabilitate offenders with a focus on inmate employment.

In 1827, the Western State Penitentiary was built in Allegheny County and in 1829 the Eastern State Penitentiary was built outside Philadelphia. Act 23 of 1829, enacted through the influence of the Pennsylvania Prison Society, ordered that the fundamental program of penal administration at both facilities be solitary confinement at hard labor.  This solitary system of prison labor failed at Western Penitentiary due to the small cells, which lacked adequate air and light, making solitary work impossible. Instead, labor at Western Penitentiary was conducted in common congregate workshops and the system of solitary confinement was abandoned. In fact, an Act of 1869 allowed the desired congregation of prisoners for industrial purposes and, by 1873; the congregate shop system was installed at Western Penitentiary. During this time, Western developed a diversified industrial program where the production of shoes, cocoa mats, hosiery, and brooms continued into the twentieth century.”

The institution also housed the only Confederate Prisoners of War in Pittsburgh. From August of 1863 to March of 1864, the incarcerated included 118 Officers of the Confederate Calvary. Today SCI Pittsburgh houses “minimum to lower-medium security male inmates needing alcohol and other drug treatment.” It’s on the banks of the Ohio River and is located about 5 miles from downtown Pittsburgh.


The ringtone may make you think of trains or the sounds of old steam-whistles that were set off when folks changed shifts at big factories (a sound I’m familiar with because of sitcoms and cartoons). Be sure to listen to the quiet and haunting exasperated “moans” at the end of the tone. Here’s the bittersweet Western Pen Whistle Tone–a sound that functions as an infrequent emergency alert signal, an everyday sound to those neighboring (and affiliated with) the historic institution, and if you’re someone ‘in the know,’ it may be a reminder of freedom or confinement.


Filed under Locally Toned (all posts), Ringtones